FinalOct 15, 2016 · Spartan Stadium
Team1234Final
Northwestern712211454
Michigan State14314940

Game flow

Northwestern won by 14 · 16 scores
Lead changes
1
0 times tied
MSU biggest lead
+14
Q1 8:31
NW biggest lead
+17
Q4 5:02
Time in front
MSU 30% · NW 61%
tied 9% · 18:11 vs 36:42 of game clock
+21+10.5Tie+10.5+21Q1Q2Q3Q4▲ Michigan State ahead▼ Northwestern aheadQ1 9:53 · MSU Passing Touchdown: Josiah Price 15 Yd pass from Brian Lewerke (Michael Geiger Kick) (NW 0, MSU 7)Q1 8:31 · MSU Interception Return Touchdown: Justin Layne 43 Yd Interception Return (Michael Geiger Kick) (NW 0, MSU 14)Q1 3:32 · NW Rushing Touchdown: Justin Jackson 29 Yd Run (Jack Mitchell Kick) (NW 7, MSU 14)Q2 14:15 · MSU Field Goal Good: Michael Geiger 41 Yd Field Goal (NW 7, MSU 17)Q2 10:04 · NW Passing Touchdown: Austin Carr 9 Yd pass from Clayton Thorson (Jack Mitchell Kick) (NW 14, MSU 17)Q2 9:23 · NW Safety: Joe Gaziano Safety (NW 16, MSU 17)Q2 6:42 · NW Field Goal Good: Jack Mitchell 33 Yd Field Goal (NW 19, MSU 17)Q3 13:28 · NW Passing Touchdown: Flynn Nagel 57 Yd pass from Clayton Thorson (Jack Mitchell Kick) (NW 26, MSU 17)Q3 6:49 · NW Rushing Touchdown: Clayton Thorson 9 Yd Run (Jack Mitchell Kick) (NW 33, MSU 17)Q3 5:54 · MSU Passing Touchdown: R.J. Shelton 59 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Michael Geiger Kick) (NW 33, MSU 24)Q3 2:08 · MSU Passing Touchdown: R.J. Shelton 86 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Michael Geiger Kick) (NW 33, MSU 31)Q3 1:53 · NW Kickoff Return Touchdown: Solomon Vault 95 Yd Kickoff Return (Jack Mitchell Kick) (NW 40, MSU 31)Q4 8:25 · NW Rushing Touchdown: Justin Jackson 26 Yd Run (Jack Mitchell Kick) (NW 47, MSU 31)Q4 7:10 · MSU Passing Touchdown: Donnie Corley 9 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Two-Point Pass Conversion Failed) (NW 47, MSU 37)Q4 5:02 · NW Passing Touchdown: Austin Carr 29 Yd pass from Clayton Thorson (Jack Mitchell Kick) (NW 54, MSU 37)Q4 0:56 · MSU Field Goal Good: Michael Geiger 35 Yd Field Goal (NW 54, MSU 40)

The lead after every score: above the line Michigan State is ahead, below it Northwestern. Each dot is a score in the scoring team's colour; hover one.

Scoring summary

1st quarter
9:53MSU
TD Josiah Price 15 Yd pass from Brian Lewerke (Michael Geiger Kick)3 plays, 39 yds, 1:21 · from NU 39
NW 0–7 MSU
8:31MSU
TD Justin Layne 43 Yd Interception Return (Michael Geiger Kick)
NW 0–14 MSU
3:32NW
TD Justin Jackson 29 Yd Run (Jack Mitchell Kick)8 plays, 61 yds, 2:43 · from NU 39
NW 7–14 MSU
2nd quarter
14:15MSU
FG Michael Geiger 41 Yd Field Goal 9 plays, 52 yds, 4:17 · from MSU 25
NW 7–17 MSU
10:04NW
TD Austin Carr 9 Yd pass from Clayton Thorson (Jack Mitchell Kick)12 plays, 75 yds, 4:06 · from NU 25
NW 14–17 MSU
9:23NW
SF Joe Gaziano Safety
NW 16–17 MSU
6:42NW
FG Jack Mitchell 33 Yd Field Goal 7 plays, 33 yds, 2:37 · from MSU 49
NW 19–17 MSU
3rd quarter
13:28NW
TD Flynn Nagel 57 Yd pass from Clayton Thorson (Jack Mitchell Kick)4 plays, 75 yds, 1:32 · from NU 25
NW 26–17 MSU
6:49NW
TD Clayton Thorson 9 Yd Run (Jack Mitchell Kick)10 plays, 86 yds, 3:28 · from NU 14
NW 33–17 MSU
5:54MSU
TD R.J. Shelton 59 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Michael Geiger Kick)3 plays, 75 yds, 0:55 · from MSU 25
NW 33–24 MSU
2:08MSU
TD R.J. Shelton 86 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Michael Geiger Kick)1 play, 86 yds, 0:11 · from MSU 14
NW 33–31 MSU
1:53NW
TD Solomon Vault 95 Yd Kickoff Return (Jack Mitchell Kick)
NW 40–31 MSU
4th quarter
8:25NW
TD Justin Jackson 26 Yd Run (Jack Mitchell Kick)13 plays, 91 yds, 6:18 · from NU 9
NW 47–31 MSU
7:10MSU
TD Donnie Corley 9 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Two-Point Pass Conversion Failed)5 plays, 76 yds, 1:09 · from MSU 24
NW 47–37 MSU
5:02NW
TD Austin Carr 29 Yd pass from Clayton Thorson (Jack Mitchell Kick)6 plays, 47 yds, 2:07 · from MSU 47
NW 54–37 MSU
0:56MSU
FG Michael Geiger 35 Yd Field Goal 7 plays, 11 yds, 1:26 · from NU 29
NW 54–40 MSU

Drives

MSU 7/15 scoredNW 9/17 scored
QStartTeamFromPlaysYdsTimeResult
Q115:00MSUMSU 256382:30Punt
Q112:30NWNU 1341:16Punt
Q111:14MSUNU 393391:21Touchdown
Q19:53NWNU 35341:22Interception Touchdown
Q18:31NWNU 25330:43Punt
Q17:48MSUMSU 10371:33Punt
Q16:15NWNU 398612:43Touchdown
Q13:32MSUMSU 259524:17Field Goal
Q214:10NWNU 2512754:06Touchdown
Q29:58MSUMSU 53-50:35Safety
Q29:19NWMSU 497332:37Field Goal
Q26:37MSUMSU 20321:08Punt

Win probability

Northwestern 100% · pregame line Michigan State −6.5 (closing line)
Q1Q2Q3Q4▲ Michigan State▼ NorthwesternMichigan State +37% win probability: Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 86 yds for a TD, (Michael Geiger KICK)Northwestern +36% win probability: Kevin Cronin kickoff for 60 yds , Solomon Vault return for 95 yds for a TD, (Jack Mitchell KICK)Northwestern +26% win probability: Clayton Thorson pass complete to Flynn Nagel for 57 yds for a TD, (Jack Mitchell KICK)Michigan State +20% win probability: Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 59 yds for a TD, (Michael Geiger KICK)Northwestern +19% win probability: Clayton Thorson pass complete to Austin Carr for 9 yds for a TD MICHIGAN ST Penalty, offside defense ( Yards) declined, (Jack Mitchell KICK)

The pregame line (TDC's for this week's games, the closing betting line for past ones), blended with the score, clock and field position (calibrated on every 2024–25 FBS play). Gold dots mark the biggest swings; hover one.

Box score

PassingC/ATTYDSAVGTDINTQBR
Clayton Thorson27/352818.03181.3
RushingCARYDSAVGTDLONG
Justin Jackson341885.5229
Clayton Thorson5122.419
John Moten IV8121.505
Solomon Vault111.001
Team3-4-1.300
ReceivingRECYDSAVGTDLONG
Austin Carr1113011.8229
Flynn Nagel58116.2157
Andrew Scanlan23216.0020
Macan Wilson2157.508
Justin Jackson4102.508
Solomon Vault284.007
Garrett Dickerson155.005
InterceptionsINTYDSTD
Jared McGee100
KickingFGPCTLONGXPPTS
Jack Mitchell1/1100.0337/710
PuntingNOYDSAVGTBIn 20LONG
Hunter Niswander521442.80062

Biggest plays

MSU +37% Q3 2:08 Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 86 yds for a TD, (Michael Geiger KICK)
NW +36% Q3 1:53 Kevin Cronin kickoff for 60 yds , Solomon Vault return for 95 yds for a TD, (Jack Mitchell KICK)
NW +26% Q3 13:28 Clayton Thorson pass complete to Flynn Nagel for 57 yds for a TD, (Jack Mitchell KICK)
MSU +20% Q3 5:54 Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 59 yds for a TD, (Michael Geiger KICK)
NW +19% Q2 10:04 Clayton Thorson pass complete to Austin Carr for 9 yds for a TD MICHIGAN ST Penalty, offside defense ( Yards) declined, (Jack Mitchell KICK)

Team stats

StatNWMSU
1st Downs2618
3rd down efficiency10-195-16
4th down efficiency1-10-1
Total Yards490475
Passing281424
Comp/Att27/3527/42
Yards per pass8.010.1
Rushing20951
Rushing Attempts5123
Yards per rush4.12.2
Penalties4-255-34
Turnovers12
Fumbles lost01
Interceptions thrown11
Possession35:3424:26

Play by play

Q4 0:00 End of 4th Quarter
Q4 0:56 2nd & 11 at MSU 38 TEAM run for a loss of 1 yard to the MchSt 39
Q4 0:56 1st & 10 at MSU 37 TEAM run for a loss of 1 yard to the MchSt 38
Q4 0:56 Kevin Cronin kickoff for 7 yds
Q4 0:56 Timeout NORTHWESTERN, clock 00:56
Q4 0:56 4th & 0 at NU 18 Michael Geiger 35 yd FG GOOD
Q4 1:14 3rd & Goal at NU 25 Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Monty Madaris for 7 yds to the Nwest 18
Q4 1:14 Timeout NORTHWESTERN, clock 01:14
Q4 2:22 2nd & Goal at NU 10 Tyler O'Connor sacked by Ifeadi Odenigbo for a loss of 15 yards to the Nwest 25
Q4 2:22 1st & Goal at NU 10 Tyler O'Connor pass incomplete to Monty Madaris
Q4 2:22 3rd & 4 at NU 23 Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Jamal Lyles for 13 yds to the Nwest 10 for a 1ST down
Q4 2:22 2nd & 10 at NU 29 Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 6 yds to the Nwest 23
Q4 2:22 1st & 10 at NU 29 Tyler O'Connor pass incomplete to Donnie Corley
Q4 2:31 4th & 4 at NU 49 Hunter Niswander punt blocked by Edward Barksdale blocked by Edward Barksdale Jalen Watts-Jackson return for 13 yds to the Nwest 29
Q4 2:31 Timeout MICHIGAN ST, clock 02:31
Q4 4:09 3rd & 8 at NU 45 John Moten IV run for 4 yds to the Nwest 49
Q4 4:09 2nd & 11 at NU 42 John Moten IV run for 3 yds to the Nwest 45
Q4 4:09 1st & 10 at NU 43 John Moten IV run for a loss of 1 yard to the Nwest 42
Q4 5:02 4th & 3 at NU 43 Tyler O'Connor pass incomplete to R.J. Shelton, broken up by Kyle Queiro
Q4 5:02 3rd & 3 at NU 43 Tyler O'Connor pass incomplete to Monty Madaris, broken up by Montre Hartage
Q4 5:02 2nd & 10 at 50 Tyler O'Connor run for 7 yds to the Nwest 43
Q4 5:02 1st & 10 at 50 Tyler O'Connor pass incomplete to Donnie Corley
Q4 5:02 1st & 10 at MSU 25 R.J. Shelton pass complete to Donnie Corley for 25 yds to the 50 yard line for a 1ST down
Q4 5:02 Jack Mitchell kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
Q4 5:02 4th & 6 at MSU 29 Clayton Thorson pass complete to Austin Carr for 29 yds for a TD, (Jack Mitchell KICK)